Defining Fair Punishment - 744 Words

â€Å"The first and greatest punishment of the sinner is the conscience of sin.† Lucius Annaeus Seneca What is the purpose of punishment? Ultimately a fair and effective punishment must not only prevent future transgressions, but also teach a valuable life lesson. While some punishments may seem standard: a grounding for breaking curfew, a detention for misbehaving in class, a jail sentence for robbery, not all punishments are so cut and dry. Take the case of Casey Heynes. A video which has since gone viral depicts the March 2011 incident. Ritchard Gale, 12, appears to tease and taunt Casey, 15, and unleash a few unretaliated punches. In response, Casey picks Ritchard up, and slams him to the ground. While Ritchard was relatively physically unscathed in the encounter, Casey could have inflicted quite serious damage. It was revealed through family and witness interviews that Casey was indeed provoked, and had suffered bullying at the hands of classmates for years. Regardless, school and societal rules were broken, and consequences must follow. What then, is a fair punishment ? Casey Heynes should receive a four day at-home suspension. In addition, he should participate in a bullying prevention group at his school and attend a one day anger management course. This represents a fair punishment, as it acts as a reasonable deterrent, allows Casey to demonstrate remorse, and is reflective of both Casey and Ritchard’s feelings. In order for a punishment to beShow MoreRelatedEthical Practices And The Supervision And Treatment Of Prison Populations1731 Words   |  7 Pages it will further exam how inmates under the supervision of correctional staff treat inmates while they are incarcerated by not allowing them the due process that they are required to have. Finally, this paper will also analyze cruel and unusual punishment these inmates receive while under the supervision of correctional staff. Ethical practices related to the supervision and treatment of prison populations 3 The population of inmatesRead MoreIn Rural Settings, Van Tassel-Braska And Hubbard Found1516 Words   |  7 Pageswhat is fair treatment for students who break the rules. When dealing with these students, there will still be students who do not operate by those rules and others who do. So if a student from both of these areas breaks the same rule, but one has broken the class rules repeatedly while the other has not, is it fair to punish them both the same? This is where finding a punishment for both may come out as â€Å"favoritism†, but is it fair to set back one students’ learning when a lesser punishment can affectRead MoreCriminology And The Social Theory Essay1726 Words   |  7 Pagesto look at criminal behaviour in a micro sense as ‘an intricate understanding of crime initiates thorough conceptualisation of people and wider society in relation to crime.’ Due to the nature of criminology as a study, there comes a problem with defining what crime itself is. The ‘father of criminology’ Lombroso was recognised as having a stream of thought known as ‘The Lombrosian Project’. This method of approach highlighted the need to examine characteristics of ‘criminals’ and ‘non-criminals’Read More Lawrence Kohlbergs Stages of Moral Development Essay548 Words   |  3 Pagesare backed by punishment, obedience for its own sake and avoiding the physical consequences of an action to persons and property. At Stage 2 there is the early emergence of moral reciprocity. The Stage 2 focused on the value of an action. Reciprocity is of the form, you scratch my back and Ill scratch yours. The Golden Rule becomes, If someone hits you, you hit them back. At Stage 2 one follows the rules only when it is to someones immediate interests. What is right is whats fair in the senseRead MoreEssay on Moral Development in Youth Sport1424 Words   |  6 Pageswith society. What we think, how we act, and what our beliefs are play a crucial role in our morality. Most believe that moral behavior is not something that in innate, but that it is something that is learned through observation. The concepts of fair play and sportsmanship are taught directly and indirectly from the coaches, parents, and others during the development of the child. Moral behavior is learned from observing others and is a result of intellectual development One important factorRead MoreWhy Independence Is Important And How It Is Vital For The Success Of Our Accounting Firm979 Words   |  4 Pagestopics to hammer in the idea of independence: SEC punishment, financial services, value-added fee arrangements, and prohibited tax services. 1) SEC Punishment The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) acted in a timely and appropriate manner when addressing the forbidden arrangements that were discovered from PwC and PwCS. Although the punishments were deemed harsh, the repercussions were appropriate in this case. The harsh nature of the punishments stemmed from the speculation of the SEC that PwCRead MoreA Report on Due Process Rights645 Words   |  3 Pagesas the guarantee that those accused of criminal acts receive fair treatment and are fully aware of the legal ramifications of their statements and actions when in the custody of the authorities. Firstly, the protections the due process clauses guarantee come in the form of the procedure that the government is required to follow when trying a person for a crime. These protections guarantee that the defendant in a trial receives fair treatment and include the right to know the accusations and theRead MoreThe Sexual Offences Bill 2015 Essay1255 Words   |  6 Pagesoffence of defilement with a child between the age of sixteen and eighteen years is liable upon conviction to imprisonment for life†. This proviso id as regards the defilement of children and the parts 2, 3, and 4 give age brackets and the liable punishment upon conviction for the crime. What would have been however more clearly defined is a single proviso with a specific age of a child as opposed to the categorization of different age brackets. More importantly is the failure of the bill of specifyRead MoreTragic Case of Ralph Tortorici897 Words   |  4 Pagesfilm I felt that the court did not give Ralph T ortorici a fair trial. First of all, Ralph had demonstrated a history of mental illness for most of his life and nothing was done to correct his illness, then the Judge also decided to proceed with the trial despite the evidence from the evaluation of the psychiatrist that Ralph was clearly not mentally stable and he needed to be hospitalized, and lastly Ralph was given an unjust and cruel punishment leading to his suicide due to the lack of help for hisRead MoreEssay Power of Society676 Words   |  3 PagesSociety has always been the defining point of a group of people’s ideas and how they believe things should be done. In The Scarlet Letter, Nathaniel Hawthorne created a fictional society in which a woman who committed adultery is punished by society, yet there is nothing she can do about it. I agree with how Nina Baym interprets Hawthorne’s ideas about society is that it is greater in number, that it can penetrate an individual so deeply that an independent self i s not imaginable, and that several